His work
In his Jami‘, he often commented on a report’s reliability. He helped readers understand why scholars did or did not rely on it.
His discussions of hidden defects grew from close study with al-Bukhari, whose judgments he consulted about narrators and transmission chains. Biographical accounts also remember al-Bukhari transmitting from his pupil outside the Sahih. The relationship was therefore more than one-way instruction. Al-Tirmidhi’s critical works preserve that exchange and show why a chain that looks acceptable at first sight may still require comparison with other transmissions.
Teaching
He also described how scholars used reports when deciding religious rules. His book brings the report and its practical interpretation together.
His frequent use and explanation of hasan helped give that category an enduring role in hadith assessment, though scholars differ over whether he first introduced the term technically. He also recorded disagreement among jurists alongside reports and sometimes discussed weak material rather than silently excluding it. Readers therefore encounter both evidence and the history of its interpretation, an important reason his Jami‘ remained useful for comparative legal study.